Post Sex Nachos go beyond being merely “your second favorite boy band.” Atwood Magazine interviewed the band ahead of their Chicago performance during The Minor League Tour. Their humor, comfort, and synergy are evident both in their live shows and their music.
A Mr. Coffee machine whirred in the background.
It was 5 p.m. on a Friday, and the members of Post Sex Nachos were gearing up before playing for a sold-out audience in Chicago. A surprisingly calm atmosphere enveloped the green room.
Four out of five members were present: Sammy Elfanbaum, lead vocalist; Chase Mueller, bassist; Mitch Broddon, guitarist; and Hunter Pendleton, drummer. (Since keyboardist Kevin Jerez is expecting a child, Jack Hazel is touring as his substitute.)
“We’ve always had incredible connections with Chicago,” Broddon remarked. “We have friends here who consistently come out to show their support.”
Post Sex Nachos is firmly rooted in the Midwest. They originated at the University of Missouri (Mizzou) and have performed everywhere from house parties to festivals. Their show at Bottom Lounge on February 28, 2025, marked their first Chicago performance since Lollapalooza.
“Dear reader, I just knocked on wood.”
Post Sex Nachos © Annaliese Baker
It’s fair to say the performance was a success. The band is on The Minor League Tour until the end of April, followed by a brief festival stint at the start of summer.
The chemistry among Post Sex Nachos shines brightly—they clearly enjoy each other's company. Their friendships and passion for music form the group's foundation. Despite having known each other for years, they effortlessly include those around them into the band’s dynamic.
Many people love to hear the story of how couples meet. When asked about their first impressions of one another, the room fell silent for a moment before bursting into laughter.
“I thought Mitch [Broddon] was very reserved,” Pendleton said after a brief pause, with everyone quickly agreeing. “Mitch is now one of the funniest and most outspoken people I know.” He gestured towards Elfanbaum and Mueller, saying, “I have a dislike for these two. And that hasn't changed.”
“I’m honestly hurt that you said nice things about me while making lightly mean comments about them,” Broddon responded. He and Elfanbaum grew up together in St. Louis, but he joined Post Sex Nachos when the band was just three-fifths of what it is now. “It felt like joining a group of brothers.”
Elfanbaum looked up from his spot on the couch. “Whoa.”
The four shared a laugh, agreeing that describing themselves as a brotherhood encapsulated their bond perfectly.
“I already knew Chase [Mueller] very well,” Elfanbaum shared. “And when Hunter [Pendleton] came aboard, I thought, ‘This is awesome! We’ll finally have someone intelligent in the band.’”
Mueller quickly chimed in to support this statement.
“And then when Mitch [Broddon] joined,” Elfanbaum continued, “I sensed it would instantly feel right.”
“Not because of his brains,” Broddon added, “at that juncture.”
The intimacy of Post Sex Nachos was evident from the start. As they rounded out the band—for this tour and during their time at Mizzou—they consistently gelled well together. They recognize that such relationships are crucial and valuable, especially as they stay together at all times while on tour.
“Like when someone walks into the room,” Pendleton noted, “and the energy just clicks? That’s a rare occurrence.”
Before Post Sex Nachos became what they are now, they had several members who were exceptionally talented musicians but didn’t mesh with the group personally. This disconnect was clear to Elfanbaum, Mueller, Broddon, Pendleton, and their fans alike.
“Mitch [Broddon] and I used to have terrible chemistry on stage,” Mueller recalled, prompting laughter from the others. “Somebody pointed it out, and we worked hard to improve.”
At their Chicago performance, Mueller and Broddon frequently gravitated towards each other. They often congregated at center stage alongside Elfanbaum, while fans at the barricade eagerly snapped photos, shouting lyrics and buzzing with excitement.
Post Sex Nachos © Annaliese Baker
They’ve been intentional about channeling their natural, close-knit relationship into their performances. Their humor intertwined with meaningful narratives is evident in their song lyrics too. Titles often range from clever and straightforward to amusingly catchy, such as “We’re All Dying, Want Some Juice?” or their album ‘Your Second Favorite Boy Band.’
As the band mentioned, some of these titles may not appear in the chorus—or any lyrics at all. They enjoy the process of making music and wish for their audience to share in that joy, whether live or while streaming.
The tour will feature his largest headline show in London to date, taking place at the famous Roundhouse in the city.
The new song from the Cardiff quartet explores the damaging culture related to body image.
The NYC trio will also be back in the UK next month for a series of intimate in-store performances.
The frontman of The National will launch the sequel to 2020’s ‘Serpentine Prison’ later this spring.
71-year-old guitarist Masayoshi Takanaka captivated fans with a setlist full of hits, offering enthusiasts of an international genre a unique, unforgettable performance at LA's Wiltern Theatre.
Ray Lozano is back with a new single titled 'CAN'T LOVE'. Now available, this track embodies her forward-thinking soul vision—navigating R&B conventions, Ray showcases her ability to
Post Sex Nachos are not just “your second favorite boy band.” Atwood Magazine chatted with the group ahead of their Chicago performance on The Minor League Tour. Their humor, comfort with one another, and chemistry are evident in their live shows and music.